HomeTaxAppeal vs Square Deal Tax
A sourced, side-by-side comparison of HomeTaxAppeal and Square Deal Tax — fee model, coverage, refund terms, and what each one actually gives you. Every Square Deal Tax fact below is quoted from its own public statements with the date we checked it.
HomeTaxAppeal vs Square Deal Tax at a glance
| Feature | HomeTaxAppeal | Square Deal Tax |
|---|---|---|
| Service type | Self-service software — you file yourself | DIY report generator — "Get assessor-grade comps report to win your property tax protest. Flat fee. You keep 100% of your savings." Explicitly anti-agent ("Property tax agents take away 30-50% of your savings!"). Operated by SQD Taxtech LLC. (per publicly stated terms as of Jul 18, 2026, source) |
| Pricing | Flat $79 one-time evidence packet — no contingency, no percentage of savings | $69 flat per report; "Pay for your report only after you are convinced"; bulk pricing for 10+ properties by contact. (per publicly stated terms as of Jul 18, 2026, source) |
| Coverage | All 50 states | 41 supported counties — predominantly Texas (Harris, Dallas, Tarrant-area, Bexar, Travis, Collin, Denton, Fort Bend, El Paso, and others) plus Cook County IL, Los Angeles CA, and Miami-Dade FL. (per publicly stated terms as of Jul 18, 2026, source) |
| Refund / guarantee | Published no-reduction guarantee (see terms) | Published refund policy (v1.3, revised 2026-04-23): refund eligible within 14 days if the report "does not identify a meaningful difference" between assessed value and comparable values, or lacks "sufficient comparable data." Not refundable: custom reports, bulk purchases, discounted reports, reports where a meaningful difference IS identified, or "Reports with a LOW case strength." Refund equals the purchase price minus payment-gateway charges. (per publicly stated terms as of Jul 18, 2026, source) |
| Comparable sales shown before you pay | Yes — the free check shows real comparable sales before you pay | Partially — "View Property Report Summary for FREE!" and a free savings estimate by address before purchase; full comp detail is in the paid report. (per publicly stated terms as of Jul 18, 2026, source) |
| What you get | An evidence packet: comparable sales, adjustments, a county filing checklist, and a hearing script — you file the protest yourself | "Recommended property value," "Equity and/or Sales comparison," and "Value calculations and explanations"; testimonials reference an "Equal & Uniform Comparable Grid," 7-10 comps, a CDU-factor appendix, and a complimentary CAD-evidence review. A downloadable sample report is available. (per publicly stated terms as of Jul 18, 2026, source) |
What it costs over time
Square Deal Tax sells a $69 flat-fee report with no contingency (squaredeal.tax/pricing, as of Jul 18, 2026), vs HomeTaxAppeal's $79 one-time flat fee. Both are one-time flat fees with no recurring or contingency component, so there is no multi-year escalation to model; the comparison is a one-time price comparison.
| Period | HomeTaxAppeal | Square Deal Tax |
|---|---|---|
| 1 year | $79 flat | $69 (Square Deal, one report) vs $79 (HomeTaxAppeal) one-time — Square Deal is $10 cheaper per report |
| 3 years | $79 flat | $69 vs $79 — both one-time flat fees; a new report in a later year is a new $69 purchase, on the same new-purchase basis as HomeTaxAppeal |
| 5 years | $79 flat | $69 vs $79 — both one-time flat fees; a new report in a later year is a new $69 purchase, on the same new-purchase basis as HomeTaxAppeal |
What Square Deal Tax reports about itself
Figures Square Deal Tax publishes about its own results, quoted as-is. These are the company's own claims — HomeTaxAppeal has not independently verified them.
- "In 2025, Square Deal customers saved an average of $700 in actual property taxes." (per publicly stated terms as of Jul 18, 2026, source)
- Cites Harris County 2025 data that DIY protesters had a "71% success rate compared to 16% for agent represented protests," with a DIY median reduction of "$20,640 vs. $13,202" (county data they cite, not their own outcome). (per publicly stated terms as of Jul 18, 2026, source)
When Square Deal Tax is the better choice
No single option fits everyone. Square Deal Tax is likely the better fit if:
- Lowest one-time price matters most. For a single season, compare Square Deal Tax's published flat fee (see the pricing above) against HomeTaxAppeal's $79. If a few dollars is the deciding factor, the cheaper packet wins.
- You don't need a free preview or a guarantee. HomeTaxAppeal shows real comparable sales in a free check before you pay and publishes a no-reduction guarantee. If neither of those matters to you, another flat-fee packet may serve just as well.
Square Deal Tax — Frequently Asked Questions
How much does Square Deal Tax charge?
$69 flat per report; "Pay for your report only after you are convinced"; bulk pricing for 10+ properties by contact. (per publicly stated terms as of Jul 18, 2026).
Is Square Deal Tax legit?
Yes — Square Deal Tax is a real, operating company. The comparison above summarizes its service model, pricing, and refund terms straight from its own site (as of Jul 18, 2026). Whether it is the right fit depends on whether you want a full-service option or a lower-cost self-service packet.
Square Deal Tax vs doing it yourself — what's the difference?
Square Deal Tax gives you a do-it-yourself packet you file yourself. HomeTaxAppeal is self-service software: it shows real comparable sales in a free check before you pay, then gives you a $79 flat-fee evidence packet — comparable sales, adjustments, a county checklist, and a hearing script — and you file the protest yourself.
Does Square Deal Tax offer a refund or guarantee?
Published refund policy (v1.3, revised 2026-04-23): refund eligible within 14 days if the report "does not identify a meaningful difference" between assessed value and comparable values, or lacks "sufficient comparable data." Not refundable: custom reports, bulk purchases, discounted reports, reports where a meaningful difference IS identified, or "Reports with a LOW case strength." Refund equals the purchase price minus payment-gateway charges. (per publicly stated terms as of Jul 18, 2026).