Start free check →
Menu

HomeTaxAppeal vs Home Tax Shield

How We Compare

FeatureHomeTaxAppealHome Tax Shield
Pricing modelFlat-fee packetHybrid: $30 flat annual subscription fee per parcel + 30% contingency on first-year tax savings achieved. Subscription auto-renews January 1 each year. Success fee only charged if assessed value is reduced. Company positions this as '40% below the industry average' vs pure-contingency peers.
CoverageAll 50 statesTexas only; residential property tax protest. Operates across approximately 48 Texas counties (expanded from 8 at founding in 2020; as of company blog 2021 'over 70% of Texans'); San Antonio HQ (legal entity: Voce Ventures, Inc.). No multi-state or commercial offering.
Your evidencePrepared for youYou do it yourself

Pricing Over Time

Home Tax Shield: $30 annual subscription + 30% of first-year savings per protest season. Using HomeTaxAppeal's conservative baseline of $1,000 annual tax reduction (Home Tax Shield's own homepage claims 3–5% reduction on average; on a $400K home at ~2.2% tax rate, 3% reduction ≈ $264/yr savings; on $500K home, ~$330/yr — HomeTaxAppeal's $1,000 baseline is generous for this competitor but consistent with TX metro benchmarks). Year 1 total = $30 + (30% × $1,000) = $330. Recurring: $30/yr subscription + 30% of any savings each protest year. HomeTaxAppeal: $79 one-time flat fee, homeowner files DIY with evidence packet. Math assumes homeowner protests every year; subscription fee is mandatory regardless of savings outcome.

PeriodHomeTaxAppealHome Tax Shield
1 year$30 + 30% × $1,000 = $330 vs $79 (≈4.2×)
3 years($30 × 3) + (30% × $1,000 × 3) = $90 + $900 = $990 vs $79 (≈12.5×)
5 years($30 × 5) + (30% × $1,000 × 5) = $150 + $1,500 = $1,650 vs $79 (≈20.9×)