What evidence do I need for an Indiana property tax appeal?
What evidence do I need for an Indiana property tax appeal?
The strongest evidence is recent comparable sales of similar nearby homes near the January 1 assessment date, plus proof of any record errors (wrong square footage, room count, or condition) and documentation of defects that lower your home's value.
An Indiana appeal is won on evidence, and comparable sales lead.
Comparable sales. Pull recent arm's-length sales of similar nearby homes — close in size, age, style, and condition — and weight those nearest the January 1 assessment date. If the comps support a value below your assessed figure, that gap is your case. Our reports build this from county assessor public records and licensed real estate data providers; every comparable can be independently verified through public records.
Record errors. Check your property record card for mistakes — wrong square footage, room or bath count, lot size, or condition grade. A factual error that inflates the assessment is often the easiest reduction to win.
Defects. Photos and repair estimates documenting issues that reduce market value (foundation, roof, water damage, deferred maintenance) can support a lower value.
How to present it. Bring it to the informal conference with the assessor first; most appeals resolve there. If it goes to the PTABOA, present the same organized evidence at the hearing.
Keep the two-way risk in mind. Because the PTABOA can raise as well as lower, the evidence needs to clearly point to a reduction before you file.
Also asked: Indiana property tax appeal evidence · comparable sales Indiana assessment appeal · how to prove overassessment Indiana